Comet 浏览器评测：抢先体验、内置 AI，没什么新意 --知识铺

我厌倦了这些懒惰的人工智能功能成为新软件的唯一卖点。

更多回复

Perplexity 会将您的所有数据出售给第三方，想象一下，Corer 会扫描您浏览器上的所有内容，而不是亲自在那艘船上

隐私条款💀☠️

在您的原始帖子中，您声称他们出售数据，然后您发布了隐私条款，而他们却说他们不出售数据？

更多回复 更多回复

更多回复

哦，你在每台设备上的所有操作，包括你使用每台设备的导航方式和你的流量来源， 都会被收集并出售，用于投放定向广告。除非你完全脱离网络，否则你只能接受这些认知。即使你拒绝了许可，即使你处于隐身状态。他们正在学习并构建你的数字身份。最好相信。

更多回复 更多回复

I mean the CEO himself said they want to learn everything about you, both from inside and outside the app. They want to use that to build a dossier, and of course, sell you ads, and marketing data is where the gold mine is. He basically wants Google on steroids.

Now, if you are fine with that, I have no problem, as everyone has their right to their balance of functionality vs privacy, but it is going to easily be the largest data grabber, even over Microsoft and Google.

I work with many of these companies; I see a lot of what they do with data. It would be very ignorant to say your data will not be sold. It absolutely will.

更多回复 更多回复

浏览器中的人工智能，去他的。还好我用的浏览器没有内置人工智能（这玩意儿）。我其实试过 Comet（通过候补名单后面的隐藏下载链接），只是想看看他们有没有在人工智能方面有什么新花样。本质上，每次你搜索 Perplexity 都会回答你的问题，而不是真正地搜索。有时候我搜索了也没结果，却给了我一个摘要。总的来说，这更糟糕。而且，他们会出售你所有的数据。所以千万别用 COMET！！！千万别用！！！！！！

在我看来，下载链接只提供了 Perplexity 功能，Agentic 浏览功能需要邀请才能解锁。它本质上就是 Project Mariner，而且非常酷。

我个人使用 Zen，因为我看重它的设计，但总的来说最好的选择是 Librewolf。

更多回复 更多回复我不知道这是否是 Comet 的较新更新，但它确实控制你的标签页并在该标签页中为你做一些事情……这绝对不是人工智能的胡扯

如果我让它打开一个 colab，编写一个程序，自行排除故障，然后进入睡眠状态，我醒来时就会发现程序基本正常运行

对于 dia 和那些内置人工智能聊天的浏览器，我完全同意你的观点，但 Comet 完全不同，我真心认为它是浏览器的未来。我还没有换浏览器，因为我不喜欢它的用户界面、速度和易用性，但它的功能本身就非常非常吸引我。

更多回复 更多回复

读完“谷歌浏览器是否被人工智能打脸了”后就别再读下去了

更多回复 更多回复

perplexity 明确指出 Comet 浏览器将收集所有数据

有人记得在 2010 年代有人抱怨安装了 Facebook 的应用程序后电池耗电更快吗？这里可能也存在同样的情况。

更多回复 更多回复 更多回复

换句话说，它只是一个带有 AI 的侧分屏，许多其他浏览器已经具备此功能，只不过这个浏览器对隐私的侵犯程度更高。

You can get it to carry out tasks on the current page, and even transfer info between tabs - just by typing in the assistant box.

更多回复 更多回复

还有一个名为 Dia 的浏览器，我还没有尝试过，所以对此不做评论。

这不就是 Arc 的开发者们干的吗？哥们，我之前可是挺喜欢 Arc 的，不过我被坑了一次……

嗯，它显然与这个浏览器类似，我认为他们的主要目的是收集我们的数据并更好地构建他们的人工智能，老实说，人工智能浏览器注定会失败，Arc 在当时是最佳选择，是一款打破交易的浏览器

更多回复

“没什么新鲜事吗？”

Your data will be used to develop features, just a have patience and let them collect data to add more features. Make sure to visit every site and fill every form that includes your personal information so they can collect that data faster to develop features.

that anyone expected anything else out of a browser produced by an AI company is pretty amusing, frankly.

I used Comet for 5000 Discord orbs and then deleted it.

i wish there was a third option instead of firefox/chromium mods

更多回复There is technically servo as well which is pretty neat, but Mozilla didn’t really develop it enough before just dropping it completely. It’s slowly becoming more usable as an actual web engine though and hopefully will be another viable option in a few years.

更多回复 更多回复

i like things without a built in , if i need i use it on chapt gpt

Im gonna be honest, its regular browser but with ai assistant thats all, nothing discovered ;)

im gonna download it and search up “fuck ai” for the discord quest

Yo soy fiel a Firefox, no sé, me gusta, solo me estoy instalando el comet porque ofrece una jugosa recompensa en Discord. Me pregunto en que momento las IAs se volvieron lo principal en cuanto a innovación para los software (hablando específicamente de este tema) es solo mi opinión, puedo estar perfectamente equivocado y me disculpo si es el caso.

更多回复

can everyone in this comment section shut the fuck up ur data is worthless nobody cares about some random fucking privacy dude who’s paranoid about every single app it probably only sells like which website u visited the most and stuff every fucking app does that google steals ur data more than the browser ur already getting ur data stolen might aswell just use the browser and use the free ai google is selling ur data to perplexity anyways use ur fucking brain ur using Android iPhone Windows all of that steals ur data Intel CPU too the browser definitely steals less than anything else talking about a long time Linux windows bsd user with privacy complaints it just doesn’t make sense what any of you guys are saying

更多回复

The only cool part is that the browser can browse and complete tasks by itself with no apis. Comet is the only browser that could access my schoolwork and e texts other browsers with AI couldn’t “see” them maybe there is a blocker put on by my school but Comet bypasses it

It’s basically a browser with AI tools. You should be able to use AI on every browser

更多回复

Conversely, I find it really good. I can get it to parse my unstructured meeting notes in one window, grab the action points for me, and add them to my todo list application - all from typing in one command.

更多回复

It looks like Zen but with horizontal tabs

Can you invite me? I heard that you need an invitation to be able to use it.

Totally agree. It’s just a new flavor and probably dia is better. For me, trying to find new browsers who are building new stuff and new ways to interact. Arcblock ArcSphere is super cool.

Hello, if someone can invite me, I’d be glad to try.

Hello I have a Fellow browser code and can invite people to Dia browser. Could you please share the Comet browser invite code with me so I can share both codes with you? Thank you.

Would love to get an invite. Happy to share it back.

I’m really excited for sky.app It was supposed to be released in Summer. So expecting it to launch around Sep-2025.

Perplexity just updated their referral system.

New users now get 1 free month of Perplexity Pro(instead of $10 off)!

You can use my link to try it for free. You can also earn up to 12 more months by referring others:

https://perplexity.ai/pro?referral_code=1T9P377S

&

I have invites for those who want to get Comet Browser quickly. You can DM me, so I can give you the invites.

更多回复

What are some chrome AI extensions that would make these AI browsers unnecessary?

Why the hate for Comet ? Maybe most of the guys in Dev here, for you it may not be such a big deal - but for many who are simply using Chrome, Edge, Safari and doing repeated tasks, for them Comet is a game-changer! Instructing a browser to do and execute things accurately on your behalf is BIG! No mainstream browser has been able to do that flawlessly till now. Privacy concerns remain .. not doubting that .. but what is really private now with AI scanning every cell of your body everywhere! We are the ones creating and welcoming it - for the Average Joe - its important what works for them and what is simple for them to use to increase their efficiency.

idk it’s actually pretty good. The agent in Comet is far superior to ChatGPT agent. I had it work through a spreadsheet and it was pretty accurate with that. It was a simple task but it still saves you time if you want to delegate a bunch of simpler tasks to it while you go do something else in a different window.

The privacy stuff is terrible though and the main reason why I will be using it sparingly. But the features are actually pretty darn good, especially for certain work related tasks. Not sure I’ll be using it for general browsing though, I’ve heard people claiming it can help you find promo codes at checkout and automatically try the codes one by one until something works.

I have ideas for several use cases that I haven’t tried it for, but it’s managed to make a good first impression for m.e

Just bury Perplexity. They lack originality. Their search engine is fundamentally a wrapper for LLM API calls, while their Comet browser is a repackaging of the Chromium framework with an AI agent. And he wants to kill Google. Seriously, Aravind. Stop it.

Chat 5.0 is faster on Comet than on Chrome primarily because Comet is built from the ground up with AI integration at its core, allowing more efficient, real-time AI responses and seamless task automation within the browser environment. Comet’s architecture supports context-aware AI that manages multi-step tasks directly, reducing latency and the need to switch between apps or tabs, unlike Chrome which has AI features added on top of a traditional browsing framework. Additionally, Comet aims to optimize AI workflows and minimize interruptions, enhancing perceived speed for AI chat interactions. Key reasons for Chat 5.0’s speed advantage on Comet: • Comet uses a built-in conversational AI assistant designed for real-time, cross-tab intelligence and automation, reducing delays in task execution. • Comet’s AI is integrated natively, allowing faster summarization, answers, and contextual understanding compared to Chrome’s add-on AI layers which can be slower and more disjointed. • The browser environment in Comet is optimized for rapid AI interactions, whereas Chrome is optimized for traditional web navigation with AI features layered afterward, potentially causing slower AI response times. • Comet’s workflow automation reduces the need for multiple manual steps, speeding up overall AI-driven experiences compared to Chrome’s more manual process. Though Comet is still in beta and may lag behind Chrome in pure browsing benchmarks, its AI-first architecture enables faster, smoother AI chat experiences like Chat 5.0 compared to Chrome. In short, the speed difference is due to Comet’s AI-centric design prioritizing seamless, context-aware chat and task completion, unlike Chrome’s traditional browser framework with AI added on.

The browser keeps prompting to set as “Default browser”. I cross it, few hours later it reappears

Baixei e fui testar, o meu antivírus acusou um Cavalo de Tróia no meu computador, desinstalei na hora.

Just watched a video about it on discord, how braindead do you have to be to need AI to do everything for you in a browser?

更多回复

I’m sorry but any browser that requires me to pay a fucking subscription to get all of the features is a hard pass for me.

There’s actually useful features like you can use it to claim every free games from gog and epic games for example. Or use it to automate something similar. I’ve personally just enjoyed the usage. I really doesn’t care about them disclosing my personal information as google, Facebook etc has already done so. I recommend.

Why do I even need this browser if I can use all Perplexity features in any other browser?

更多回复

Theres another browser called Fellou that actually seems pretty unique- it’s an agentic browser that can actually do things for you like check your calendar by actually going to google calendar and looking at it. it shows what it’s doing and everything. I have played with it a bit but not enough to get used to it or see how it can be used maximally. But I think anything that is doing agentic stuff would be the next useful function of AI so I like the idea at least.

I use Linux…. not available……. is a shame because for documenting projects Perplexity has no rival

Puedo usar prompts para analysis financiero en tiempo real? He escuchado que tiene memorial persistent por un dia entero, quiero que haga analysis de mercado y me indique si hay alguna action o etf con desplome de sobre venta extrema y alta probabilidad de revote. Tambien saber si es capaz de analizar y discirminar usando distintas metricas para luego enviarme una alarma y notification al movil avosandome de que es buen momento para comprar

Тогда лучший браузер в котором не передают информацию это Edge и Chrome и для безопасности или всё же лучше Tor?

The latest update to chrome pooched all of my accessibility settings. On my macos I have all of the inverted text and accessibility tweaks working. But there are some websites that just do not invert. So there’s a half a dozen dark Extensions that allegedly work on chrome but this new version none work. So big deal…. Except I can’t see my banking site. That’s not good.

Downloaded comet. Everything works Tickety boo. So they must be using an older version of chrome????

///

Chess.com just told me that if I download Comet I get free chess.com premium. I’m not careful about what companies get my data; I use facebook regularly, I use the sign “Sign in with Google” button for most websites. Is there a reason why Comet would be worse for my data than what I already do? Is there anything Comet would be selling that isn’t already for sale? Figure if you’re selling my data, I might as well get the chess account out of it.

guys i installd it and uninstalled it

Can you opt out of data retention?

Washington post offers a free month if I use this browser. What do ya’ll think? I haven’t tried to do it. “Get FREE access to The Post in the Comet browser through November 13

Create an account to read this article, plus enjoy all articles completely free when you visit us using the Comet browser.”